🔗 Share this article

A prominent western historian, a leading scholar of the American frontier, has written a latest volume titled Brothers of the Gun, which explores the lives of the famed lawman and Doc Holliday. He notes annoyance with the oft-quoted line from a renowned cowboy film: “When the legend becomes fact, print the legend.”

“All writer cites it, they just beat it to death,” the author says cheerfully. “And it’s actually not accurate. I wrote a story. I want people to be engaged in the period, but I just get so tired of that quote. The myth is legend. It won't become truth. People can retell the legend but it won't make it reality.”

That Famous Showdown at the OK Corral

In Arizona's Tombstone, on a day in October 1881, Earp and Doc Holliday were took part in a shootout that is remembered as the Gunfight at the OK Corral. Joined by the Earp brothers, the duo confronted the Cowboys, men hunted for theft and cattle theft. In under 60 seconds, three gang members were dead and Doc was hurt, as were Virgil and Morgan Earp.

Despite being one of many western scraps between officers and criminals, it became legend, partly thanks to iconic films including the John Ford film and another renowned film.

Mystery and Contradiction in Historical Testimonies

“A lot of what we learn about it is confirmable,” he said of the true battle and its consequences. “But I consistently go back to one of the best remarks, and it’s a very simple comment. An observer, who witnessed the shootout, remarked: ‘I don’t know. It was all a blur.’”

Including the witnesses there had varying versions. Statements from the investigation is likewise unclear. Observers who were allies of the Cowboys were untruthful, and every version is a bit different. It’s rare when somebody concurs on anything.

“Everything was chaotic.” – an eyewitness

“Including the participants involved were bewildered,” he adds. “So it’s genuinely difficult to get at it, and it took place in half a minute.”

Myth-Making and Hollywood Portrayals

Wyatt Earp persisted into the movie period, succumbing in 1929 at the years of 80. Initially shown on a silent movie screen in the 1920s, he later became the subject of major mid-century westerns. In relatively modern decades, he has been acted by an actor in Tombstone and Kevin Costner in the 1994 movie.

The historian digs through such legend-building to find the men beneath. His works explore the span of the Wild West, from the famous outlaw and Pat Garrett to the notorious bandit.

Layered Lives of Wyatt Earp and Holliday

Hailing in Illinois in 1848, Earp was not old enough to serve in the civil war, though he sought to do so. When he was twenty, he was appointed a law officer in Lamar, Missouri. Errors were made. Earp suffered a calamity with the passing of his wife, Urilla Sutherland, from disease in 1870. Later, as a official, he kept revenue he gathered.

“We can't know why he retained it,” he states. “He escapes, and finds himself in Oklahoma. He’s detained for swiping a mount, and then he’s in Illinois, and he’s managing a brothel. In time he goes back to the frontier, and he settles in Kansas.”

In spite of his checkered past, Wyatt excelled as a lawman. Newspapers applauded him repeatedly. In one case, he detained a inebriated man who had $500 on him. He held the cash for the drunk and handed it back when he released him from confinement.

Divergent Characters of the Partners

Gardner emphasizes the stark difference between the pair. Earp was aspiring, aiming to advance himself and reach offices like county sheriff. Holliday, born in Georgia in the mid-19th century, was a dentist turned risk-taker. Different from Earp, Holliday didn't exhibit signs of becoming stable.

“Holliday just travels from one boomtown to the next one,” the author notes. “He never really evolve. And part of that’s his obsession to wagering. Part of that is tuberculosis, managing that and using substances, whether it’s with drink or eventually laudanum.”

Influence and Historical Significance

The new book shows a fascinating facet of the frontier: the friction between authority and chaos, and the attempts of leaders to impose order over developing societies. The degree of bureaucracy that resulted from a gunfight – hearings, statements, decrees for restitution – might astonish those acquainted with simplified versions of the period.

Additionally, Earp and Holliday were entangled in divisive politics. He was a member of the GOP, while Tombstone sheriff a Democrat was a opponent, creating a conflict for control and authority.

Ultimately, Gardner avoids to romanticize these men. Wyatt and Doc passed periods on each end